In the world of family sitcoms, Full House and Family Matters occupy two of the most beloved spots. Both shows were staples of the 80s and 90s, focusing on heartwarming family dynamics, lighthearted humor, and life lessons. And yet, many fans and critics have often compared these two series, with some even suggesting that Family Matters was a mere copycat of Full House.
But is it true? Was Family Matters really the Full House copy it could never be, or did it evolve into something entirely unique? In this article, we’ll dissect these two iconic shows, comparing their themes, characters, and legacies, and determine whether Family Matters stood in the shadow of Full House or carved its own path in television history.
The Origins: How Family Matters and Full House Came to Be
Before we jump into the comparison, let’s take a moment to explore the origins of both shows. It’s crucial to understand the context of each show’s creation.
The Rise of Full House (1987 – 1995)
Premiering in 1987, Full House quickly became one of the most iconic family sitcoms of its time. Created by Jeff Franklin, the show focused on widowed father Danny Tanner, played by Bob Saget, who is forced to raise his three daughters with the help of his brother-in-law Jesse (John Stamos) and best friend Joey (Dave Coulier). Set in San Francisco, the series was known for its wholesome, heartwarming moments, quirky characters, and catchy theme song.
What made Full House stand out was its portrayal of non-traditional family dynamics. While Danny was raising his daughters, he was also trying to balance his career and personal life, with a lot of comedic situations involving his quirky friends and family members. The show’s message of family togetherness and unconditional love resonated with audiences, leading to its massive success.
The Evolution of Family Matters (1989 – 1998)
Family Matters premiered in 1989, just two years after Full House. Created by William Bickley and Michael Warren, Family Matters was initially a spinoff of Perfect Strangers, with the character of Carl Winslow (Reginald VelJohnson), a Chicago cop, being introduced as the neighbor of the two main characters of Perfect Strangers. However, Family Matters soon evolved into a family-focused sitcom, shifting the spotlight to Carl’s home life, his wife Harriette (Jo Marie Payton), and their children.
Much like Full House, Family Matters embraced themes of family and love. However, it quickly became known for the antics of Steve Urkel (Jaleel White), the nerdy, clumsy neighbor who would soon steal the show with his catchphrase, “Did I do that?” Urkel’s popularity took Family Matters from a family sitcom into a pop culture phenomenon.
Key Similarities Between Full House and Family Matters
At first glance, it’s easy to see why Family Matters and Full House are often compared. Here are some of the key similarities:
1. Family-Centric Themes
Both shows revolve around family dynamics. While Full House is centered around a father raising his daughters with the help of family and friends, Family Matters focuses on the Winslow family, headed by Carl and Harriette, navigating life’s challenges together. Both shows emphasize the importance of family love, support, and togetherness.
2. A Strong Father Figure
Another striking similarity is the presence of a strong, loving father figure. In Full House, Danny Tanner is the central parental figure, while in Family Matters, Carl Winslow plays a similar role. Both characters are funny, caring, and always there for their families, even when they don’t have all the answers.
3. Supporting Characters Add to the Comedy
In both shows, the supporting characters add humor and life lessons to the storylines. Full House has Jesse and Joey, who are quirky yet loving figures in the lives of the Tanner girls. Similarly, Family Matters has Steve Urkel, whose antics are at the heart of many of the show’s most memorable moments. Both shows effectively balance heartwarming family moments with lighthearted comedy from the supporting cast.
The Key Difference: Steve Urkel and the Evolution of Family Matters
While Full House was an ensemble sitcom with a central focus on family and friendship, Family Matters quickly distinguished itself with the breakout character of Steve Urkel. Urkel’s popularity skyrocketed, and soon, he became the central focus of the show. His physical comedy, awkwardness, and unique personality drew in viewers, and the show evolved into a vehicle for Urkel’s antics and character development.
This shift was stark. While Full House remained centered around the Tanner family and their everyday lives, Family Matters began to revolve around Urkel’s various schemes, transformations, and romantic pursuits, especially his unrequited love for Laura Winslow (Kellie Shanygne Williams).
The Unique Appeal of Family Matters vs. Full House
While both shows had a similar family-oriented appeal, Family Matters set itself apart by embracing more outrageous, outlandish humor—largely driven by Urkel’s character. Here’s a breakdown of their unique qualities:
1. Full House: A Balanced Family Drama with Heart
Full House was always grounded in a sense of family drama mixed with humor. Its characters were relatable, and the situations were often realistic, despite the comedic tone. The show’s narrative remained consistent, and the humor never overshadowed the heart of the show, which was about love, growth, and family values.
2. Family Matters: Comedy with a Twist of Fantasy
Family Matters ventured into the realm of fantasy and farcical comedy, especially with Urkel’s many misadventures. From creating a “Urkelbot” to transforming into the suave “Stefan Urquelle,” Family Matters often leaned into larger-than-life moments that set it apart from Full House‘s more grounded family drama. The show embraced the absurd, which made it beloved in its own right.
The Legacy: What Makes Each Show Unique
While Full House remains one of the most iconic family sitcoms in American TV history, Family Matters carved out its own legacy, thanks in large part to Steve Urkel’s influence on pop culture. The two shows may share a similar structure, but they offered audiences different experiences:
Full House: Timeless, Heartfelt, and Family-Oriented
The enduring appeal of Full House lies in its timeless portrayal of family values. It showed the beauty of a non-traditional family and dealt with issues that were both heartwarming and relatable, making it an easy favorite for audiences of all ages.
Family Matters: A Comedy That Evolved with Its Characters
Family Matters capitalized on its early family-oriented storylines before transforming into a full-fledged comedy with Steve Urkel as the star. Its cultural impact cannot be overstated, with Urkel becoming one of the most recognizable TV characters of all time.
Could Family Matters Ever Have Been a Full House Copy?
It’s clear that Family Matters wasn’t just a Full House knockoff—it was a show that found its own voice in a crowded television landscape. While it may have started with similarities, Family Matters quickly evolved into something uniquely its own, thanks to characters like Steve Urkel and the show’s penchant for over-the-top comedy.
Conclusion: The Enduring Appeal of Two Iconic Shows
Both Full House and Family Matters hold cherished places in television history. Though they share certain similarities—such as their family-centered stories and lovable characters—they each offer distinct flavors of humor and heart. While Family Matters may have been compared to Full House, it is undeniable that it stood on its own, thanks in large part to Steve Urkel’s larger-than-life presence.
As fans continue to revisit these beloved sitcoms, it’s clear that both shows made lasting impacts on American pop culture. Whether you prefer the warm, family-focused approach of Full House or the quirky, comedic chaos of Family Matters, both shows remain timeless classics.
FAQs
- Is Family Matters a spin-off of Full House? No, Family Matters is not a spin-off of Full House. It is a spin-off of Perfect Strangers, featuring the character Carl Winslow.
- What made Steve Urkel such a memorable character? Steve Urkel became a standout character due to his nerdy, clumsy nature, catchy catchphrases like “Did I do that?” and his constant schemes to win over Laura Winslow.
- Why did Family Matters shift focus to Steve Urkel? Steve Urkel’s popularity grew immensely, and the producers leaned into his character to boost ratings, eventually making him the focal point of the series.
- What is the legacy of Full House in pop culture? Full House became a quintessential family sitcom that portrayed the ideal of a loving, supportive family. Its influence can still be seen in modern family TV shows today.
-
Which show is more relatable: Full House or Family Matters? Full House might be considered more relatable for its realistic portrayal of family dynamics, while Family Matters focused more on outlandish humor and slapstick comedy.
