Kevin Costner is known for his versatility as an actor, but it’s his roles in Western films that really showcase his connection to America’s rugged past. From quiet, introspective cowboys to morally conflicted lawmen, Costner’s performances in the Western genre have earned him a spot among the greats. But not all of his Western films are created equal. Some stand out as masterpieces, while others don’t quite hit the mark.
In this article, we’ll rank all six of Kevin Costner’s major Western films, from his iconic role in Dances with Wolves to his later work in films like The Postman. Let’s take a look at these films, evaluate their merits, and see how they rank in terms of acting, storytelling, and the true grit of the American West.
1. Dances with Wolves (1990)
Best Western Movie of Kevin Costner’s Career
It’s no surprise that Dances with Wolves takes the top spot in this ranking. The film, directed by and starring Kevin Costner, is a monumental achievement in the Western genre. Costner plays Lt. John Dunbar, a Union soldier who befriends the Lakota Sioux tribe during the American Civil War. The film’s themes of cultural exchange, friendship, and understanding were groundbreaking for its time.
Not only did Dances with Wolves win seven Academy Awards, including Best Picture and Best Director for Costner, but it also helped to redefine the Western genre by shifting the focus to Native American perspectives. Its sweeping cinematography, emotional depth, and exploration of human relationships have earned it a place in the cinematic pantheon.
Why It Stands Out:
- A sweeping epic that balances historical drama with a deep emotional core.
- A unique take on Native American culture, told from a sympathetic perspective.
- Iconic performances, particularly from Costner and his supporting cast.
2. Open Range (2003)
A Strong Contender for Western Perfection
Open Range is another Kevin Costner-directed Western that earns a high rank on this list. Costner plays Charley Waite, a grizzled cowboy who, along with his partner Boss Spearman (Robert Duvall), is forced to confront a corrupt rancher in a small frontier town. This film feels like a love letter to the traditional Western, with its stunning landscapes, slow-burn storytelling, and intense final showdown.
The film’s balance between moments of quiet reflection and heart-pounding action makes it a standout in Costner’s Western portfolio. While it may not have the same grandiosity as Dances with Wolves, Open Range succeeds because of its grounded approach and the palpable chemistry between Costner and Duvall.
Why It Stands Out:
- A return to traditional Western themes like justice, honor, and the open frontier.
- Powerful performances, especially from Costner and Duvall.
- A climactic gunfight that ranks among the genre’s best.
3. Wyatt Earp (1994)
A Relatively Underappreciated Take on the Legendary Lawman
Costner’s portrayal of the legendary lawman Wyatt Earp is a bit of a mixed bag but still one of his most ambitious Western films. Directed by Lawrence Kasdan, Wyatt Earp attempts to capture the full complexity of Earp’s life, from his early years to his involvement in the infamous Gunfight at the O.K. Corral. While some criticize the film for being too long and meandering, Costner’s portrayal of the tough, stoic Earp is engaging, and the film’s exploration of the myths and realities surrounding the Western icon is fascinating.
The film benefits from strong support from its cast, including Dennis Quaid as Doc Holliday and Gene Hackman as Earp’s father. Though it may not reach the heights of other Westerns, Wyatt Earp is a solid and ambitious historical drama.
Why It Stands Out:
- A deeper, more nuanced portrayal of a famous Western figure.
- Strong performances from the supporting cast, particularly Dennis Quaid.
- Historical accuracy in depicting Earp’s life, even if it occasionally drags.
4. The Postman (1997)
A Post-Apocalyptic Western That Misses the Mark
While The Postman isn’t traditionally viewed as a “pure” Western, it’s still very much in the Western genre’s spirit—set in a post-apocalyptic America where one man, played by Kevin Costner, restores order and hope through the act of delivering mail. Directed and starring Costner, the film presents an idealistic vision of rebuilding society after its collapse. Unfortunately, while The Postman has a solid premise, it’s ultimately a bloated and uneven film that struggles to find its narrative focus.
Despite its shortcomings, there’s still enjoyment to be had in the film’s grand ambition and Costner’s earnest performance. However, The Postman is not a strong contender in the world of Western cinema.
Why It Doesn’t Stand Out:
- A confusing and overblown plot that feels disconnected from its Western roots.
- Attempts to blend post-apocalyptic themes with the classic Western feel but doesn’t quite succeed.
- A lack of real emotional depth or strong secondary characters.
5. The Hatfields & McCoys (2012)
A TV Miniseries That Dips into Western Violence and Feuds
While The Hatfields & McCoys isn’t a traditional film but rather a three-part miniseries, it still deserves recognition for Costner’s strong performance in this historical Western drama. Based on the infamous real-life feud between two Appalachian families, this miniseries takes a gritty, violent look at one of the most famous conflicts in American history. Costner plays Devil Anse Hatfield, the patriarch of the Hatfield clan, while Bill Paxton portrays his rival, Randolph McCoy.
The miniseries benefits from Costner’s intense performance and the compelling narrative of feuding families, but its episodic structure limits its ability to delve deeper into the characters and themes. Still, it stands as a solid, if not entirely groundbreaking, work in the Western genre.
Why It Stands Out:
- A compelling true-story-based plot that delves into one of America’s most famous family feuds.
- Costner’s commanding performance as Devil Anse Hatfield.
- Strong period details and well-executed action scenes, despite its limited runtime.
6. Silverado (1985)
A Decent, If Unremarkable, Early Western Effort
Silverado was one of Kevin Costner’s early Western roles, and while the film is enjoyable, it’s far from the standout performances that would come later in his career. Directed by Lawrence Kasdan, this film features an ensemble cast, including Scott Glenn, Kevin Kline, and Danny Glover, and tells the story of a group of outlaws who come together to protect a small Western town from corruption. Costner plays the young, idealistic Paden, a character who is still finding his place in the world.
Though Silverado has some good action scenes and lighthearted moments, it suffers from a lack of real emotional depth and struggles to distinguish itself from other Westerns of the time. It’s an entertaining watch but doesn’t offer much more than that.
Why It Doesn’t Stand Out:
- A relatively standard plot that feels too familiar compared to other Westerns.
- Underdeveloped characters that don’t leave a lasting impact.
- Costner’s performance, while solid, doesn’t elevate the film to greatness.
Conclusion: Kevin Costner’s Western Legacy
Kevin Costner has undoubtedly made a significant impact on the Western genre, both through his iconic performances and his work behind the camera. From Dances with Wolves to Open Range, his films have provided a fresh take on classic Western tropes, breathing new life into the genre while honoring its roots. While not every Western film in his career is a masterpiece, Costner’s contributions to the genre will be remembered for years to come.
FAQs
1. Which is the best Kevin Costner Western movie? Dances with Wolves is widely regarded as the best Kevin Costner Western, winning multiple Academy Awards and becoming a cinematic milestone.
2. What is the worst Kevin Costner Western? The Postman is often considered one of Kevin Costner’s weaker Western efforts due to its confused plot and overblown narrative.
3. What is Silverado about? Silverado is a classic Western about a group of outlaws who team up to save a small town from corrupt forces. While entertaining, it doesn’t stand out as a groundbreaking film in Costner’s career.
4. Is Wyatt Earp worth watching? Yes, though it may not be as strong as other Westerns, Wyatt Earp offers a more nuanced portrayal of the iconic lawman, making it a worthwhile watch for fans of historical dramas.
5. What was Kevin Costner’s role in Open Range? In Open Range, Costner plays Charley Waite, a seasoned cowboy who is forced to fight for justice in a small town, alongside Robert Duvall’s character, Boss Spearman.
