Dolly Parton has graced our screens with her incredible acting talent, magnetic personality, and unmistakable charm. Two of her most iconic roles are in 9 to 5 and Steel Magnolias, each showcasing a different side of Dolly’s versatile acting abilities. But when it comes to choosing a favorite, the question is: Which movie truly reigns supreme? Is it the sassy, workplace comedy of 9 to 5, or the heartwarming, Southern drama of Steel Magnolias?
In this article, we’ll break down what makes each of these films a beloved classic and dive into the reasons why Dolly Parton’s roles in them have become iconic. Let’s explore both films and see which one truly captures the essence of Dolly’s unparalleled star power!
1. 9 to 5: The Workplace Comedy That Changed the Game
The Plot and Dolly’s Role
Released in 1980, 9 to 5 is a workplace comedy that stars Dolly Parton alongside Jane Fonda and Lily Tomlin. The film centers around three women who work in a male-dominated office environment and are fed up with their sexist boss. Dolly plays Doralee Rhodes, a sweet yet feisty secretary who, despite her attractive appearance, is unfairly labeled as the boss’s “bimbo.” Doralee and her colleagues plot to take down their tyrannical boss, played by Dabney Coleman.
Dolly’s portrayal of Doralee is both endearing and empowering. Her character is both smart and fun-loving, and Dolly’s portrayal brought the perfect mix of sass and heart to the role. Not only did the film challenge workplace norms, but it also had a cultural impact, making Dolly Parton an even bigger icon in pop culture.
Why 9 to 5 is a Fan Favorite:
- It’s a sharp, witty commentary on gender inequality in the workplace, with humor that still resonates today.
- Dolly’s performance as Doralee is iconic—she is both a symbol of strength and sweetness.
- The film’s theme song, “9 to 5,” became a massive hit and is still associated with Dolly’s legacy.
2. Steel Magnolias: A Heartwarming Southern Drama
The Plot and Dolly’s Role
Steel Magnolias (1989) is a Southern drama that’s become a staple in both cinematic history and in the hearts of viewers. The film takes place in a small Louisiana town and focuses on the lives of a close-knit group of women who support each other through both joyous and tragic times. Dolly plays Truvy Jones, the sweet and sassy owner of the local beauty salon who offers wisdom and solace to her clients, including M’Lynn (Sally Field), whose daughter, Shelby (Julia Roberts), is battling a serious health condition.
While Dolly’s role in Steel Magnolias is not as comedic as her portrayal of Doralee, it’s no less memorable. Truvy is full of warmth, humor, and heart, offering support to her friends during one of the most difficult moments in their lives. Dolly brings her signature charm to the character, making her a beloved part of the ensemble cast.
Why Steel Magnolias is a Timeless Classic:
- The movie is an emotional rollercoaster, filled with moments of both laughter and tears.
- Dolly’s portrayal of Truvy adds levity and joy to the otherwise heavy story.
- The film highlights the power of female friendship, making it relatable and touching for many viewers.
3. The Themes: Empowerment vs. Heartfelt Sisterhood
Empowerment in 9 to 5
9 to 5 is primarily about the empowerment of women in a workplace setting. The film focuses on breaking barriers, fighting for fairness, and showing that women can be just as successful and assertive as their male counterparts. It’s a comedy that challenges societal norms while also providing laughs and camaraderie. Dolly’s character, Doralee, is a beacon of empowerment, fighting against the stereotypes and mistreatment she faces at work.
Heartfelt Sisterhood in Steel Magnolias
Steel Magnolias, on the other hand, emphasizes the beauty and strength of female friendships, especially in the face of adversity. The women in this film share laughter, love, and tears as they navigate life’s challenges. Dolly’s character, Truvy, provides a source of lighthearted wisdom and comfort, helping her friends navigate life’s difficulties. The heartwarming message of the film focuses on the resilience of women in the face of life’s hardships.
4. Dolly’s Iconic Roles: Comedy vs. Drama
Comedy in 9 to 5: In 9 to 5, Dolly Parton’s comedic timing shines. Doralee is full of sass and wit, delivering punchlines with perfect precision. The film is fun, light-hearted, and unapologetically bold. It showcases Dolly’s ability to make serious issues—like workplace discrimination—fun while still maintaining a sense of importance.
Drama in Steel Magnolias: Steel Magnolias brings out a different side of Dolly’s acting skills. Truvy may offer humor, but the emotional weight of the film is undeniable. Dolly’s role as Truvy is layered with depth and tenderness, and her comedic charm is used in a more nuanced way. Her performance complements the film’s emotional heart, creating a balance between comedy and sadness.
5. The Supporting Cast: Stellar Performances Across the Board
Both films feature an incredible cast of actresses, but the performances in each movie highlight different aspects of Dolly’s talents.
- In 9 to 5, Dolly shares the screen with two other powerhouse actresses, Jane Fonda and Lily Tomlin. The chemistry between these three women is electric, and their teamwork is what makes the film’s workplace humor so effective.
- Steel Magnolias features an ensemble cast, including Sally Field, Julia Roberts, and Olympia Dukakis. Each actress brings something unique to the table, and together, they form a solid group of women who carry the weight of the film’s emotional drama.
Both films allow Dolly to showcase her versatility, from the humorous and bold Doralee to the wise and supportive Truvy.
6. The Music: Dolly Parton’s Signature Sound
It wouldn’t be a discussion about Dolly Parton without mentioning her musical contributions.
- 9 to 5 features Dolly’s famous theme song, “9 to 5,” which became a major hit and remains one of her most iconic tracks. The upbeat, catchy tune perfectly encapsulates the themes of empowerment and the struggles of working women.
- While Steel Magnolias doesn’t feature as many original songs from Dolly, the film’s soundtrack, including Dolly’s “I Will Always Love You,” is still deeply associated with her. The song became an anthem of love and loss, adding to the emotional weight of the film.
7. Which Movie Reigns Supreme?
When it comes to which movie is Dolly Parton’s best, it’s hard to choose just one. 9 to 5 is an empowering, hilarious film that showcased Dolly’s comedic chops and solidified her place in pop culture. On the other hand, Steel Magnolias is a touching and emotional drama that highlighted Dolly’s ability to portray depth and tenderness, while still bringing her signature warmth and humor.
Which One Should You Choose?
- If you’re looking for a fun, empowering comedy with tons of laughs, 9 to 5 is the clear choice.
- If you’re in the mood for an emotional, heartfelt film that celebrates friendship, love, and loss, Steel Magnolias is the movie for you.
Conclusion: Both Are Dolly Parton Masterpieces
Dolly Parton’s films 9 to 5 and Steel Magnolias each hold a special place in the hearts of audiences. Whether you love her bold, funny side in 9 to 5 or her heartfelt, emotional performance in Steel Magnolias, Dolly Parton has created two iconic characters that continue to resonate with fans. Ultimately, it’s not about which movie is the best—it’s about appreciating the range of roles Dolly has taken on and how she has made each one her own.
FAQs
1. Which movie made Dolly Parton a household name? 9 to 5 made Dolly Parton a household name, thanks to her role as Doralee Rhodes and the iconic theme song.
2. What is Dolly Parton’s most famous song from her movies? “9 to 5” from the movie 9 to 5 is arguably Dolly Parton’s most famous song, becoming a massive hit.
3. Is Steel Magnolias based on a true story? Steel Magnolias is based on a play by Robert Harling, which was inspired by the real-life experiences of Harling’s sister and mother.
4. Which movie has the stronger female empowerment message? 9 to 5 has a clear female empowerment message, focusing on women challenging workplace inequality.
5. What role does Dolly Parton play in Steel Magnolias? Dolly Parton plays Truvy Jones, the kind-hearted owner of a beauty salon who provides support and wisdom to her friends in Steel Magnolias.
