In the season 1 finale, it was revealed that Colter’s childhood friend Lizzy knew about an affair that was happening between her mom and Colter’s dad. She has a memory from right before Ashton died of him showing up at their house, arguing with her mother, and ultimately leaving her with a box of old research papers and journals. Whatever is in that box could lead Colter to answers to important questions, such as why Ashton Shaw left Berkeley, and what project he was working on for the United States Government.
It’s likely that whatever is in the box of files, Colter’s dad didn’t want his family to see it, hence leaving it with a close family friend. But something in the box could now lead to the truth about what happened to Ashton Shaw on the night he died, and could finally resolve the Shaw family mystery and clear Russell’s name. Lizzy’s memory of seeing Ashton around the time of his death will cause Colter to scrutinize the details of the night his father died in the upcoming season, with Colter definitely trying to get that box of files.
Season 1 left fans on the edge of their seats, staring at the infamous box of files. What could possibly be inside? Was it evidence, secrets, or something that could change everything? In this article, we break down what’s inside and what it means for the show’s storyline. Get ready for some jaw-dropping revelations!
The Build-Up: How We Got Here
Before diving into what’s inside, let’s take a moment to appreciate how this mystery unfolded. Throughout Season 1, the show teased the existence of these files, hinting at their significance. The finale finally revealed the box, but its contents remained a mystery—until now.
Breaking Open the Box: What’s Inside?
The moment of truth—what exactly was in the box? Here’s what we discovered:
- Confidential Government Documents – These papers contained classified information that could shake the foundations of the show’s universe.
- Photographs and Surveillance Reports – Images capturing moments the characters never wanted anyone to see.
- Handwritten Letters – Personal messages revealing hidden alliances and betrayals.
- A Key to an Unknown Location – Possibly leading to more shocking discoveries.
How These Files Change the Game
This box isn’t just another plot device—it redefines everything we thought we knew. Here’s why:
- It exposes lies told throughout the season.
- It reveals hidden connections between major characters.
- It sets the stage for an explosive Season 2.
Major Theories About the Box’s Contents
Fans have speculated for months about what could be inside. Here are some of the most popular theories that were either confirmed or debunked:
- Theory #1: The Files Contain Evidence of a Cover-Up – ✅ Confirmed!
- Theory #2: A Character’s True Identity is Hidden Inside – ❌ Debunked (for now).
- Theory #3: The Files Lead to a New Antagonist – ✅ Confirmed!
Character Reactions: Who Knew What?
- Protagonist’s Shocked Expression – Clearly, they weren’t expecting what they found.
- Antagonist’s Nervous Behavior – They know what’s coming, and it’s not good.
- Supporting Characters in Denial – Some refuse to believe the truth.
What This Means for Season 2
Now that the box has been opened, Season 2 is poised for major drama. Here’s what we can expect:
- New Conflicts – The revelations will pit characters against each other.
- More Mysteries – The key inside the box raises even bigger questions.
- Unexpected Alliances – Some characters may team up to protect or exploit the truth.
Hidden Clues You Might Have Missed
Sharp-eyed fans may have caught subtle hints throughout Season 1 about the box’s importance:
- An offhand comment in Episode 3 foreshadowed the key.
- A background character was seen handling similar files.
- A cryptic note in Episode 7 hinted at the government’s involvement.
Fan Reactions: Social Media Explodes
- Twitter Reactions: “I KNEW IT! That box was hiding the biggest twist ever! #MindBlown”
- Reddit Theories: “Okay, but what if the key leads to an even bigger secret?”
- TikTok Breakdowns: “Let me explain why these files will change everything!”
Why This Twist Works So Well
A great season finale twist should do three things:
- Surprise the audience – This reveal did just that.
- Change the story’s direction – The entire narrative has shifted.
- Make us eager for more – Fans can’t wait for Season 2.
The Showrunners Speak: Behind-the-Scenes Insights
In an exclusive interview, the show’s creators revealed:
- The box’s contents were decided early in production.
- Some actors didn’t know what was inside until filming the scene.
- The key will be a major focus in the next season.
What Could Be Next? Predictions for the Future
- Will the files be destroyed to protect secrets?
- Who else knew about the box before it was found?
- Is there another, even bigger secret hidden elsewhere?
Conclusion: The Beginning of Something Bigger
The box of files has completely changed the game, making Season 2 one of the most anticipated follow-ups ever. With secrets exposed, alliances tested, and new mysteries unlocked, the story is just getting started. What do you think will happen next?
